On this day:
Elizabethan era begins: Queen Mary I of England dies and is succeeded by her half-sister Elizabeth I of England.
1603
English explorer, writer, and courtier Sir Walter Raleigh goes on trial for treason
1800
The United States Congress holds its first session in Washington, D.C.
1903
The Russian Social Democratic Labor Party splits into two groups: the Bolsheviks (Russian for “majority”) and Mensheviks (Russian for “minority”).
1939
Nine Czech students are executed as a response to anti-Nazi demonstrations prompted by the death of Jan Opletal. In addition, all Czech universities are shut down and over 1200 Czech students sent to concentration camps. Since this event, International Students’ Day is celebrated in many countries, especially in the Czech Republic.
1968
Viewers of the Raiders–Jets football game in the eastern United States are denied the opportunity to watch its exciting finish when NBC broadcasts Heidi instead, prompting changes to sports broadcasting in the U.S.
1970
Luna program: The Soviet Union lands Lunokhod 1 on Mare Imbrium (Sea of Rains) on the Moon. This is the first roving remote-controlled robot to land on another world and is released by the orbiting Luna 17 spacecraft.
1973
Watergate scandal: In Orlando, Florida, US President Richard Nixon tells 400 Associated Press managing editors, “I am not a crook”.
1982
Duk Koo Kim dies unexpectedly from injuries sustained during a 14-round match against Ray Mancini in Las Vegas, Nevada, prompting reforms in the sport of boxing.
2009
Administrators at the Climatic Research Unit at the University of East Anglia discover their servers had been hacked and thousands of emails and files on climate change had been stolen, which would serve as the basis of the “Climategate” controversy. From an MIT forum, Richard Lindzen, the A. P. Sloan Professor of Meteorology, believed the e-mails were leaked by a whistleblower within the Climate Research Unit who, like Lindzen, was disillusioned by what he saw as the scientific community’s one-sided argument over climate change. “Undeniably,” he said, “we are dealing with issues illegal and unethical.” The debate, he said, is whose illegal and unethical behavior is the larger issue: the scientists or the hackers?
'All bad poetry springs from genuine feeling. To be natural is to be obvious, and to be obvious is to be inartistic.'--Oscar Wilde
***
“You have this technology that can just eliminate all this communication friction,” Rothschild, the Microsoft economist, says. “You’re going to see companies build barriers in order to maintain the consumer base that they have.”
Here’s what that could look like: Let’s say Muse becomes the default way that many people find information, shop, and manage their digital lives. In principle, users could deploy Muse to scour the internet for the content most valuable to them, connect directly with vendors, and otherwise escape the walled gardens that have defined the internet for the past couple of decades. But Meta might not want to let them do that. Instead, it might design Muse to keep users within its own walled garden—by, say, preferentially showing users content from Meta social networks and recommending businesses that have paid a fee to be featured prominently in Muse results.--from a good article on the agentic web in MIT Tech. Review
***
While there is no publicly announced restriction on male dentists treating women, a ban appears to have spread across Afghanistan, according to media reports and interviews with women and doctors by the Guardian and Zan Times. Dentists report that it has been enforced by Taliban security forces, with raids and warnings to male practitioners that they will be imprisoned if female patients are found in their clinics.
***
Thore Graepel is chair of machine learning at University College London. He was a core member of the AlphaGo team at DeepMind and works to ensure that AI benefits human flourishing. He wrote this recently in an attempt to distinguish the reasoning-insightful elements in AI.
"On an afternoon in Seoul in March 2016, I watched a program I helped build put a stone on the fifth line of a Go board in what looked like a gift to its human opponent. Move 37 in game two of the five-game match looked so absurd that some commentators thought it was a programming glitch.
When Deep Blue defeated then-reigning world chess champion Garry Kasparov in 1997, it did so by looking six to eight moves ahead per player and evaluating 200 million chess positions per second, using rules hard-coded by humans. Go is a vastly more complex game. A stone’s worth depends on how distant groups and territory unfold over dozens of moves. Computing even a fraction of the possible outcomes would take a supercomputer billions of years. To win, AlphaGo had to sense who was ahead at a glance and even invent moves no human had thought to play.
That is why many accounts of AlphaGo’s match against Lee portray move 37 as a flash of pure machine intuition. But that is a misunderstanding. It was actually AlphaGo’s powers of reasoning that made this creative choice—and these are powers that today’s AI lacks. If we want future AI systems to produce trustworthy results and really novel insights in fields like science and medicine, we need to equip them with genuine reasoning capabilities of this kind.
AlphaGo is made up of two systems. The first, its policy network, was trained to guess what move a strong human would play. This “intuitive” part regarded move 37 as nothing special—a play that had a roughly one in 10,000 chance of being made by an expert human player. What made AlphaGo choose it was the program’s search machinery, which looked beyond immediate plausibility and weighed the future consequences of proposed moves. It explicitly constructed and searched a game tree with thousands of branches, each representing a different possible future."
I suppose the questions are: are rules superseded in this insight? And can brilliance become outlaw? But escaping its algorithmic limits does not seem to be a question, which puts the risk back on the coder, a person.
