Thursday, August 2, 2012

Where Only the Very Best Can't Win

 Jordyn Wieber, the famous American gymnast, finished fourth in the overall preliminary round  behind two Americans and one Russian.

She has a storied history. She was all-around world champion in 2011. She was national champion two years in a row. She is a powerful, skilled gymnast, likely the best of an American team which might be the best team ever. Yet she will not be in the finals for the individual championship. Why? While fourth over-all, she was third on the American team in the individual preliminaries. And each team can send no more than two representatives to the individual championship finals.

Now this might be good for television ratings, this might make some lesser gymnasts happy to go and perform in the finals, it certainly will make politicians who want to "spread the wealth around" happy.

But it certainly is opposed to every tenet of competitive athletics, which values effort, ability and achievement.  And fairness.

No comments: